Kill Log

TeardownsTeardown 3 of 3

The data we wanted to sell was already free

The idea: college admissions consulting prices are opaque, so a panel of what families actually paid could be valuable. A panel's moat is private data. We checked whether the data was already public and whether anyone pays for it.

Desk validation dated 2026-11-19, Asia/Seoul time.

Verdict

Killed

20 firms publish prices. Large free surveys already give averages. We found 0 cases of families paying for price information.

20
Firms with public prices
14 first-party, 6 third-party
$150–400
Published hourly rates
10 firms
$245
Average hourly, free survey
550+ consultants
0
Cases of families paying for price data
Searched, none found

Published prices: 20 firms

We collected prices from 20 sources, 14 from the firm's own pages and 6 from third-party lists or articles. Hourly rates run from $150 to $400. Comprehensive packages run from about $2,000 to $20,000 and above. Two entries came from search summaries and need a recheck against the original page, and no page shows a publication date. Full table (CSV).

Some firms keep prices private: Comprehensive College Consulting quotes per family, and several larger firms show no price list (PrepScholar summary).

Figure 1Hourly rates published by 10 of the 20 firms
Top Dog College Admissions
$150
My Admissions Sherpa
$195
Right4U College Counseling
$200
Tip Top Admissions
$200–250
Kismet College Consulting
$225
CurtisE Learning
$275
College Admissions Coaching (CT)
$300
Ourcollegecounselor
$300
Simplified College Consulting
$300
Ivy Scholars
$400
$100$200$300$400

$245, average hourly rate in the CollegePlannerPro 2026 survey (550+ consultants)

Source: college-consulting-public-prices.csv. One firm gives an essay-only hourly rate ($275); one gives a range ($200–250). The other 10 sources show packages only.

Complaints about opaque pricing

We found 3 explicit complaints: a parent answer on Berkeley Parents Network, a consultant-written article that has a competitor's bias (Top Dog), and a review that notes the price is hidden (AcceptU review). We found 6 threads asking whether a price is fair, including one about a $9,000 package and five College Confidential threads. We read search summaries of those threads, not the full text. The sample is small.

Is anyone paying for price data?

No evidence found. Benchmarks are free:

Comparison directories are free as well: CollegeAccept lists 5,000+ counselors, and GetSet College shows prices openly. What families do pay for is answers: AdmitMatch charges $49 per month for admissions answers, not for price lists.

What this teaches

A price panel needs data that nobody else can see. Here the firms and the trade groups had already published it, and AI makes copying a public list cheap. Before building a data product, check whether the data is already public and who pays for it today.

Limits of this test

Two price entries rely on search summaries. Forum counts come from what search engines returned, not an exhaustive crawl, and Reddit was not crawled. A willingness-to-pay test with real families was not run.